Why India Looks Both Very Equal and Very Unequal on Inequality

The World Inequality Lab says India's top 1% hold 22.6% of income and 40.1% of wealth. The World Bank says India is the fourth most equal country by consumption. Both are true, and here is why.

An Indian man carries a traditional balance scale along a village street

Photo by Mehmet Turgut Kirkgoz on Pexels

How unequal is India, really?

It depends on what you measure. That is the honest first answer, and the rest of this article explains why. Two respected sets of numbers, published within a year of each other, seem to describe two different countries.

In March 2024 the World Inequality Lab published a working paper by Nitin Kumar Bharti, Lucas Chancel, Thomas Piketty and Anmol Somanchi, Income and Wealth Inequality in India, 1922-2023: The Rise of the Billionaire Raj. It found that in 2022-23 the top 1% of Indians took 22.6% of national income and held 40.1% of national wealth, the highest levels in the series that starts in 1922. The authors compared India with Brazil, China, France, South Africa, the UK and the US and found India’s top 1% income share was the highest of the group. The authors also warn that India’s economic data is of poor quality and that their figures are probably a lower bound.

In April 2025 the World Bank’s Poverty and Equity Brief for India reported that the consumption Gini, a standard measure where 0 is perfect equality and 100 is perfect inequality, fell from 28.8 in 2011-12 to 25.5 in 2022-23. As the Drishti IAS summary of the brief notes, the figure comes from the 2011-12 consumption survey and the 2022-23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES). Press coverage widely reported that this placed India fourth most equal among the countries the Bank lists, behind Slovakia, Slovenia and Belarus.

A top 1% that holds two-fifths of the wealth, and a country near the top of the world’s equality table. Both statements come from serious sources. The gap between them is the subject of this article, and it matters, because the picture you believe decides which policies look necessary.

What does the World Inequality Lab actually say?

The paper uses tax records, national accounts and surveys, and adds estimates of the very rich from rich lists. Its main findings:

  • The top 1% income share was 22.6% in 2022-23, the highest in the series. The bottom 50% earned about 15%, according to a Statista chart of the paper’s data.
  • The top 1% wealth share was 40.1% in 2022-23.
  • Inequality fell from independence until the early 1980s, then rose, with the steepest climb from the early 2000s.
  • The authors argue that the rise was driven by the top of the distribution, not by a broad squeeze on the middle.

The paper also makes a policy proposal: a modest annual tax on the super-rich, which it estimates could raise a few percent of national income and be spent on health, education and nutrition. That is a proposal, not an established result, and economists disagree on whether such a tax would work in practice. We looked at the arguments in detail in our piece on the case for a wealth tax in India.

What does the World Bank and the consumption survey say?

The Bank’s brief rests on the HCES 2022-23, which asks households what they spent over a recent period. On that basis:

  • The consumption Gini fell from 28.8 (2011-12) to 25.5 (2022-23).
  • Extreme poverty at the $2.15 a day line fell from 16.2% to 2.3% over the same period, which the Bank says lifted about 171 million people above that line.
  • At the $3.65 a day line, used for lower-middle-income countries, poverty fell from 61.8% to 28.1%.

India’s own ministry statistics office (MoSPI) reports the same direction. Its HCES 2023-24 press note of 27 December 2024 puts the rural consumption Gini at 0.266 in 2022-23 and 0.237 in 2023-24, and the urban Gini at 0.314 and 0.284. It also says the largest rise in spending between the two years was among the poorest 5 to 10% of people. These are real gains. A family that moved above the poverty line, ate better and bought a phone is better off, and the data captures that.

Why do the two pictures differ?

Four differences explain most of the gap. None of them means one team is lying.

Consumption is not income

Rich households save a large share of what they earn, and poor households spend nearly all of it. A person who earns Rs 50 crore does not spend Rs 50 crore. So a survey of spending squeezes the top end towards the middle. Income Ginis are normally higher than consumption Ginis in every country, which is why mixing the two in one league table can mislead. The Bank’s own ranking mixes surveys of both kinds, and several economists made this point after the brief came out, as in this critique in The Wire.

Wealth is not either of them

Wealth is what people own: land, houses, shares, gold, businesses. It builds up over generations and is always more concentrated than income. A salaried teacher and the owner of a large business group may spend similar amounts on daily life while holding assets that differ a thousandfold. The 40.1% figure is about ownership. The consumption Gini says nothing about it.

Household surveys miss the very rich

People with very high incomes are hard to reach and have little reason to report everything. A survey with a few hundred thousand households is unlikely to include many billionaires. Critics also note that imputed rent on owner-occupied homes is not counted in the Indian consumption data, which understates what homeowners consume. The World Inequality Lab handles this by blending in tax data and rich lists. That is a legitimate method, but it involves more estimation, and its authors say as much.

The surveys changed their method

The 2022-23 HCES asked about spending differently from the 2011-12 survey, with more detailed item lists and repeated visits. Changes of this kind can raise the recorded consumption of the poor and shift the Gini. The Bank itself flags that the two surveys are not strictly comparable. Some economists reply that even if levels are off, the trend is likely sound if the under-reporting is steady over time. Others read the same survey and report a smaller fall in inequality. The fair summary is that consumption inequality probably did fall, and by how much is still argued.

So which number should you trust?

Both, for different questions. If you ask whether the poorest Indians are eating more, owning more and spending more than a decade ago, the consumption data and the poverty counts answer yes. If you ask who owns the country’s productive assets and who gains from growth at the top, the income and wealth data answer that the top 1% have pulled far ahead. A country can be getting less poor and more concentrated at the same moment. India looks like such a case.

How does India compare with China, Brazil, South Africa, the US and the Nordic countries?

International comparisons are hard, because the countries use different surveys. The table below gives rough, widely cited positions. Treat the Gini numbers as indicative and check the source for each.

Country

What the data shows

India

Consumption Gini 25.5 (World Bank, 2022-23). Top 1% income share 22.6%, wealth share 40.1% (World Inequality Lab, 2022-23).

China

The World Bank brief places China’s Gini at about 35.7, higher than India’s, though China’s survey is income-based.

United States

The same brief puts the US Gini at about 41.8, on an income basis.

Brazil

Income Gini around 50 to 53 in recent World Bank series, among the highest in the large economies.

South Africa

Gini around 63, the highest in the World Bank’s data.

Nordic countries

Low disposable-income Ginis, roughly in the high 20s on a 100-point scale, after taxes and transfers.

Three lessons come out of that table.

First, India’s consumption Gini is not comparable to the US income Gini. If you put India’s income distribution next to the US, the World Inequality Lab finds India’s top 1% income share is higher than that of the US, Brazil and South Africa. That result is the more telling comparison, because it uses the same concept for each country.

Second, the Nordic model is not about having no rich people. Their low Ginis are measured after tax and benefits. Before taxes, inequality in Denmark or Sweden is much higher than the final figure suggests. The difference is what the state takes and returns, which is the point of the next section.

Third, South Africa and Brazil show what persistent high inequality looks like: segregated schooling, unequal land, and a large informal economy. India shares some of these features, which is why the wealth numbers deserve attention even while consumption data shows progress.

What has reduced inequality elsewhere?

The evidence from countries that did bring inequality down points to a short list of tools, most of them dull and expensive: schools, clinics, jobs and taxes.

Universal schooling and health

The Nordic countries made primary and secondary schooling free and of similar quality across social classes, and paid for health care from general taxes. A child born to a poor family ends up with a similar education to a child born to a rich one. Over a generation, that narrows the gap in earnings better than any later transfer. South Korea and Costa Rica followed similar paths on a smaller budget. See our look at how Costa Rica moved money from a standing army into schools and hospitals.

Progressive taxation and transfers

Taxes on high incomes and property, plus cash and in-kind benefits for families, do most of the work of lowering the Gini in Northern Europe. The debate in India is about how far to go. Supporters of higher taxes on top incomes and wealth say India collects too little from the top and spends too little on health and education. Opponents warn about capital flight, evasion and the poor record of past wealth taxes, several of which were repealed. A narrower option many economists accept is to tax inherited wealth and capital gains more evenly, and to close exemptions. We do not need to settle that argument here. The key point is that countries that cut inequality used taxes and public services together.

What has reduced inequality in India?

India has a set of programmes that work on the bottom of the distribution. They have lifted the floor, even if they have not touched the top.

MGNREGA

The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, passed in 2005, gives every rural household a legal right to up to 100 days of paid manual work a year. It sets a floor under rural wages, and it gives women, Dalit and Adivasi workers a source of cash income that does not depend on a landlord. Its weaknesses are well known: delayed wage payments, thin budgets in some years and uneven work across states. Even so, it is one of the world’s largest public works programmes, and its design owes much to a citizens’ campaign we have profiled in the story of Aruna Roy and the MKSS.

Direct benefit transfers

Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) sends subsidies, pensions and scholarships straight to a bank account. Its main gain is lower leakage: money that once went through several hands now arrives in the recipient’s name. It has also made it possible to reach people at scale. The limits are exclusion errors, such as Aadhaar mismatches that block a genuine claimant, and the fact that a transfer of a few thousand rupees a year cannot close a wealth gap.

Food, health cover and schooling

The public distribution system gives subsidised or free grain to a very large share of households. Ayushman Bharat PM-JAY gives hospital cover to poorer families. Free school meals bring children to class and improve nutrition. None of these is a redistribution scheme in the strict sense, but each moves resources towards the bottom, and each helps explain why consumption among the poorest grew fastest in the latest HCES.

Kerala and Tamil Nadu

Kerala is the standard example of an Indian state that raised human development early. It reached near-universal literacy (93.9% in the 2011 Census), invested in primary health centres and land reform, and has India’s lowest infant mortality rate. Its model has costs, including a heavy reliance on remittances from workers abroad and slower industrial growth. It still shows that a poor region can achieve outcomes close to those of far richer places. Tamil Nadu took a different route, with free school meals, reservations and industrial policy, which we cover in our One State One Story piece on Tamil Nadu. The shared lesson is that public spending on people, sustained over decades, changes outcomes.

Where the gaps remain

Employment is still mostly informal: the World Bank brief says only 23% of non-farm paid jobs are formal. Five states (Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Bihar, West Bengal and Madhya Pradesh) account for 54% of those living in extreme poverty. Women’s participation in paid work is low, a gap we examine in our article on why India’s female labour force participation lags Pakistan’s. These are the places where the floor is lifted but the ladder is missing.

Should India worry more about the top or the bottom?

The question is a false choice, because the two problems feed each other. A large informal workforce has little bargaining power, so wages grow slowly while profits grow fast. A tax system that raises little from the top leaves less for schools and clinics. Weak public schools and health care make the next generation’s start unequal, and wealth passes to the next generation of the already wealthy.

Economists disagree on how much the top matters. One view says that a rise in the top 1% share is not a problem if the poor are also getting better off, and that the focus should be on growth and jobs. The other view says that high concentration weakens competition, shapes politics and slows social mobility, so it needs policy attention in its own right. The evidence in India supports a mixed position: poverty has fallen sharply, which is good news, and concentration at the top is also higher than it has been in a century, which is a reason to build the public services and tax base that fund the next round of gains.

What does a fairer path look like?

Drawing on what worked in other countries and in Indian states, five priorities stand out.

  1. Better data. India has no official income survey that covers the whole population, and its tax data on high earners is not published in detail. Releasing anonymised tax statistics and running a regular income and wealth survey would settle many of the arguments in this article.
  2. Public schools and health that families trust. Spending on education and health as a share of GDP is low compared with the Nordic countries and many middle-income peers. Raising it, and measuring learning outcomes, does more for equal opportunity than any single transfer.
  3. Formal jobs and decent wages. Lifting the share of formal work, and giving women a route into paid work, reduces the gap between those with protection and those without.
  4. A fairer tax mix. This does not require a single new tax. It means looking at how much revenue comes from labour, consumption and capital, and whether high earners and large estates pay a comparable share to the rest.
  5. Protect what works. MGNREGA wage payments on time, DBT with a way to fix errors, and school meals and rations that reach the last household.

What you can do

  • Read the sources, not only the headlines. When someone says India is among the most equal or most unequal countries, ask which measure they mean: consumption, income or wealth.
  • Share the full picture. Poverty has fallen, and concentration at the top has risen. Both can be true in one conversation.
  • Use your local rights. Attend the gram sabha, check the MGNREGA muster rolls on the official portal, and ask whether wages in your area are paid on time.
  • Help a neighbour claim an entitlement. Many families miss rations, pensions or health cover because of paperwork. An hour of help can unlock years of support.
  • Support local schools and libraries. Volunteer as a reading mentor, or donate to a government school through its parent-teacher association.
  • Ask candidates the question. At the ward, panchayat or state level, ask what they will do for school quality, primary health care and jobs.
  • Pay what you owe and keep records. A tax system works only if people comply, and good records help workers prove income when they apply for credit or benefits.

Frequently asked questions

Is India one of the most equal countries in the world?

On a consumption measure, the World Bank reports a Gini of 25.5, which ranks India fourth among the countries it lists. On income and wealth, the World Inequality Lab finds the top 1% hold 22.6% of income and 40.1% of wealth. The first is about spending, the second about earnings and ownership, so the two do not conflict.

Who are the World Inequality Lab and why do they matter?

The World Inequality Lab is a research group based at the Paris School of Economics, co-founded by Thomas Piketty. It maintains the World Inequality Database. Its India figures use tax data and rich lists that standard surveys miss, though some Indian economists question its methods and its estimates of the very top.

Did inequality in India rise or fall?

It depends on the measure. Consumption inequality fell between 2011-12 and 2022-23 on the survey data, though the surveys are not fully comparable. Income and wealth concentration at the top rose, especially since the early 2000s.

What is the Gini coefficient?

It is a number from 0 to 100 that summarises how evenly something is spread. A value of 0 means everyone has the same amount. A value of 100 means one person has everything. It can be computed for income, consumption or wealth, and the results are not interchangeable.

Does a wealth tax work?

The evidence is mixed. Several European countries repealed theirs because of avoidance and low revenue, while others, such as Switzerland and Norway, still have one. Supporters in India argue that a narrow tax on very large fortunes could fund health and schooling. Critics worry about capital flight and administration. It remains an open policy debate.

Which Indian programmes help reduce inequality?

MGNREGA, the public distribution system, direct benefit transfers, school meals and PM-JAY all raise the floor. They support the bottom of the distribution and do not reduce top-end concentration.

The bottom line

India is both more equal and less equal than the headlines say. The poorest have gained, with extreme poverty at $2.15 a day falling to 2.3%, and measured consumption inequality has fallen. At the same time, the top 1% hold 22.6% of income and about 40% of wealth, levels the World Inequality Lab finds higher than at any point in its series. The countries that cut inequality did it with free, good schools and health care, work that pays, and taxes that fund both. India has begun that work with MGNREGA, DBT and a few strong state models. The next step is better data and the political will to build on it, so that the people who gained in the last decade can keep gaining.

What you can do

  • Share the evidenceSend this to one person who should know about poverty.Share on WhatsApp
  • Give an afternoonTeach, mentor, clean up, or lend your professional skills.Ways to volunteer
  • Tell us what's missingKnow a story, a fact we got wrong, or a solution worth spotlighting?Suggest a story
ShareWhatsAppXLinkedIn

Politically neutral. Every claim sourced. Report a correction.

Written by

Varun Dubey

Varun Dubey is the founder and editor of Unite 4 India. An expert who studied at Banaras Hindu University (BHU), he writes data-led explainers on India's social issues, built on official surveys, government reports and peer-reviewed research, and every piece ends with what is working on the ground.

No comments yet